REVIEW: Good Will Hunting
by Luke Buckmaster
3 and a half stars out of 5
Theres something a little unsettling about Will Hunting. Sure hes a genius born on the wrong side of the tracks, with the IQ of Einstein and a PHD in being a smart-ass. But lets look at the situation seriously: Will is smart enough to solve an equation that few people in the world are able to, but dumb enough to continuously punch a guys head in when he can hear the cops a coming. Not to mention being caught for theft, fights and other fairly pathetic crimes. He may be able to recite word for word a chapter from a book and solve complicated equations, but he doesnt seem to be quite so smart when it comes to simple everyday actions and thoughts. This is why he mucks up a good relationship with his girlfriend, lands himself in a low paying job and fails to grasp the idea of loving anybody but himself.
Will (Matt Damon) works as a cleaner at one of Americas prestigious schools. When he secretly solves a complex maths problem written on a black board, maths Professor Lambeau (Stellan Skarsgerd) attempts to track down the mystery intellect. But when he eventually discover who it is, Will has been arrested and given a prison sentence.
Lambeau is able to convince the judge to free Will on two terms: that he spends one day a week meeting with Lambeau and one day a week meeting with a therapist. After quickly humiliating two shrinks (one in a hilarious afternoon delight scene), he meets his match when introduced to the wise Sean McGuire (Robin Williams). Wills best mate (Ben Affleck) and new girlfriend (Minnie Driver) also complicate his bewildered life.
The exquisite scenes of tense and ardent drama between Will and Sean are the core of the film. The rest of it, however, is a fairly ordinary story simply told well.
Its been quite some time since Robin Williams has performed in such a mature and robust way. Many of his recent films (Flubber, Jumanji, Mrs Doubtfire) have been laughable in more ways than one. At last we have something that can stand up against the microscope and exploit Williams skill; reassuring us that he is indeed an actor capable to appeal to people above the age of twelve.
Good Will Hunting is fundamentally a fairly ordinary show. Gus Van Sant (and the films writers, Damon and Affleck) deserves credit, though, as what we have here is a solid and clever concoction of socially aware drama. But what could have been a physiological battle of emotions gets tangled up with silly little detours into childish relationships and situations.
Its good yes, but Good Will Hunting does not match up to the hype which so wholly surrounded it. It shouldnt be known as the savoir of teen dramas, the Oscar winner or the lavish masterpiece that perhaps something like Titanic is.
The thin line between good and great is often crossed in Good Will Huntings duration but only to find that it stabs itself in the foot when trying to be a far too complete film.
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews