REVIEW: The Sound of One Hand Clapping (1998)
by Luke Buckmaster
3 stars out of 5
Note to readers outside Australia: The Sound of One Hand Clapping is an Australian film shot in Tasmania, and has been selected for the 1998 Berlin film festival. As far as I know, it has not yet been slated for a US release date.
>From the haunting book comes the haunting film The Sound of One Hand Clapping is by no ones standards an easy film to watch or enjoy. I havent read the book myself, but since the writer (Richard Flanagan) is also the films director, its a fairly safe bet that what is on the screen is in close context with what Flanagan has written.
36 year old Sonja Buloh hasnt had an easy path down the road of life her mother abandoned her at the age of two, had various physical and emotional troubles through childhood and was driven to move away from her alcoholic father Bojan when she was sixteen. Now, twenty years later (and pregnant), Sonya visits him in Tasmania after all those years of absence. She discovers Bojan is distraught and aggrieved, drained of all emotion and resorting to a life of booze and cigarettes.
As Sonja begins to piece together hidden parts of her childhood, and the dark secrets of her families past, we begin to realize the severity of the pain has been subjected to. Through a draining collection of fragments from her own experiences, a detailed portrait of Sonjas suffering is powerfully painted.
The Sound of One Hand Clapping is a prime example of how one character can be carved into tragically different, isolated others. There are three main versions of Sonja Suloh the three-year-old (Arabella Wain), eight year old (Rosie Flanagan) and the present day Sonja (Kerry Fox). Through frequent flashbacks the film jumps to different times in her life, and what is impressive about this is that we are able to accurately feel the sadness and joy from most of her previous experiences. What is not impressive is that these versions of Sonja are separated far too much, so her character can never truly entrance us or keep us eagerly watching.
There are a few other things that irritated me about the film: the dialogue is bewildering and a little sluggish, _ is at times very unconvincing in her role and the Scooby Doo Family Mystery isnt all that entertaining.
What The Sound of One Hand Clapping does deliver, however, is consistent to the style it sets early in the film so if youre lucky, you can be impressed from start to finish. But on the other hand, you could hate it all too.
Either way, compliments have to be made: Kristof Kaczmarek brings an energetic and sensual presence to his role, Australian cinematographer Martin McGrath (A Little Bit of Soul, Muriels Wedding) successfully captures the beauty of the Tasmanian landscape and Cezary Skubiszewskis resplendent music composition is notably enjoyable.
If youre prepared to be exhausted and depressed by an overworked yet still impressive flick, The Sound of One Hand Clapping may hit the right note.
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews