War is hell. A point that very few, from whatever side of the fence you reside, will disagree with. A seemingly pointless, senseless loss of life, all to attain an objective that they do not understand, or even believe in. Anyone who doubts or disputes any of those statements, should sit through a viewing of Saving Private Ryan. If you can, and still hold your belief that war isn't a tragedy, for which the payoff sometimes doesn't seem worth the journey, then, I pity you.
Spielberg's vision of war, the most unabashed, undaunting, uninhibited that I've seen in a while (albeit, not being a fan, nor frequent viewer of war movies, I can't compare this fairly against them). The much-talked about opening scenes, difficult to express in words because of the intensely emotional vision painted, are worthy of the talk. They are graphic, tragic, maybe a bit over the top, but if that is the way that war really was, then I have an even stronger found respect for those who went through it. Being a a veteran of war (albeit comparing my experiences to these, would be like comparing my one year of Little League, to that of the New York Yankees, by saying.."Yeah, I played baseball") I can understand and respect some of the ideals, sentiments,a nd thoughts expressed. We often wondered (as the characters do) what's the purpose, is it worth it, questions, that have been asked through time, and may never have an answer, but this movie tries.
It is brutally honest, straightforward, it is drawn out at times, overly emotional and lingering at others. It pulls no punches, reaches into your soul and brings you there, makes you feel it. The sounds are all around you, the visions are exquisite (kudos to cinematographer Jarusz Kaminski, this movie looks amazing, with some memorable shots), the horror of it all, right in your lap.
The story involves a team of soldiers, sent to retrieve the lone surviving brother, of 4, who is somewhere in France during the Normandy invasion of 1944. Granted, you know what's going to happen, but you just don't know how, and that is where this movie succeeds. You are stuck, on the journey, like it, or not, and the only resolution, is to complete the mission.
The performances, are thoroughly effective as well. Hanks, is, well, he's Tom Hanks, he can do epics in his sleep, and he turns another effectively emotional, but not overly mind blowing (see Forrest Gump) performance. The remainder of the group, Tom Sizemore, in the best performance yet of his career, as the loyal grizzled sidekick. Edward Burns, the talented actor- director (see Brothers McMullen) as a the required tough Brooklyn-ite (do all war movies need the token New Yorker) pulls off the doubting Thomas role with a street tough sentiment. Of course the hunk-o-the-moment Matt Damon, who really isn't given much to do, but has an effective presence, and some well- placed cameos from Ted Danson, and Paul Giamatti (on a role since Howard Stern phone-whipped him in Private Parts) keep the movie flowing. But the kudos in this one, goto a trio of unknowns, Jeremy Davies (The Locusts) as the reluctant interpreter, Giovanni Ribisi, as the emotional medic, and Barry Pepper as the sniper, with God on his side. These three young stars make a presence, and add to the emotional intensity of this movie, by being seemingly the most real of the group.
Clocking in at just under three hours, you tend to lose yourself a bit, but that's the way war was, it was long, it was tiring, and it wasn't pretty or simple. This movie is not for the weak of heart, or stomach. It will effective reach inside you, leave a bit of itself in you afterwards. Is it the best movie of the summer, probably not, as some will say..I won't jump on the Oscar bandwagon yet, too early. But in a summer full of brainless, plotless, emotionless wastes of celluloid, this one stands out as an effective, if not educational and emotional, way to spend an afternoon. I would suggest this one be viewed on the big-screen, in all it's epic glamour.
See more of my Reel Ramblings at http://www.angelfire.com/ks/nearside/comingatt.html
-----== Posted via Deja News, The Leader in Internet Discussion ==----- http://www.dejanews.com/rg_mkgrp.xp Create Your Own Free Member Forum
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews