Title: Star Trek: Insurrection (1998)
Okay, I admit it. I do like to watch Star Trek on occasion, and might even consider myself a slight fan of the series. I've seen 7 of the 9 movies, and many of the episodes of Next Gen., Deep Space 9, and Voyager. A lot of the good and the bad aspects of the series in there, and the latest incarnation, "Star Trek: Insurrection" (1998) mixes both. It has the premise and the ideas of the wonderful TV series, but with the execution of some of the worst films.
"Star Trek: Insurrection" once again brings us back to the familiar company of Captain Picard, Commander Riker, Lieutenant Data, Worf, and the rest of the "Next Generation" crew. This time, we are reunited with them amidst a plot between corrupt Starfleet officials and an alien race called the Baku, who attempt to basically evict the peaceful, agrarian Sona people from their home planet, which is basically a giant fountain of youth. This, of course, is in the interests of research, as discoveries about the planet can potentially help millions of people suffering from variosu illnesses or whatnot. Of course, when Picard finds out about the intention to move these people, him and his crew revolt against the officials and their alien allies.
Now here's the main problem with the film. When I was watching it, I thought to myself, what was so bad about moving them- 600 people- if it were in the interests of millions of others? On the other hand, it _is_ the eviction of 600 innocent people. The story would have been made a lot better if it addressed this moral dilemma- do you sacrifice the few for the greater good? Rather, it answers this question way too quickly and then the story just turns into a fairly mindless "sci-fi flick", using film cliches like the child going back into a dangerous area to save his pet. And in order to try to make up for the lack of plot, it attempts for a "twist" towards the end revealing something about the relationship between the Sona and the Baku, but that twist feels contrived.
Similarly, I think the characters and their relationships seem to suffer as a result of the disappearance of strong plot as well. I liked the way things were going with the characters in the beginning, articularly the rekindling of the relationship between Counselor Troi (Mariana Sirtis) and Commander Riker (Jonathan Frakes, who also directed). The moments they shared were snappy, smart, and with some welcome sexual energy. But those moments, of course, are gone later in the film. Captain Picard also starts up a romance of his own with a young-looking Sona woman (actually a few centuries in age) and I think that the chemistry between them can be pleasant and beautiful, just like the woman herself is, but again, that suffers as the romance tries and fails to integrate into the latter half of the film with the phaser blasts going in every direction.
Many believe that today, good special effects are taking the places of a good story, and that pretty much seems to be the case with "Insurrection". The visual effects are probably the most remarkable element of this film, and are a step above those that are offered in the other Trek films. Some shots, particularly involving the Enterprise itself, are obviously computer generated, while others, like when we see more of Lt. Data's body as he strips off the "invisible" clothing that he wore, are pretty eye-opening. My personal favorite is the shot of the invisible Holodeck revealed after water had been sprayed on it.
However, none of this makes up for what I think are the foundations of a good film- characters and plot, both of which 2/3 of the film is lacking. The ideas behind this film had pretty good potential; it's disappointing to see them with relatively half-baked execution. My score out of 10: 4.5
They said they tried to make it more like the TV series, but I guess not enough.
Arnold Kim
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews