RUSH HOUR Reviewed by Jamie Peck
For the record, I don't mind Tucker much at all. Sure, he can be as irksome as fingernails on a blackboard at times, but so could Jim Carrey back in his pre-"Truman Show" days. Rather, the problem with him in "Rush Hour" is that his squealy self and frantic antics just don't sit well with the role he's playing - a rogue LAPD detective named James Carter. Check out the opening scene (which genre fans know has ultimately _very_little_ to do with the rest of the film), in which Carter takes part in a sting operation to trap an explosives dealer. Um, could he or his cop-endangering shtick be any harder to swallow?
"Rush Hour" becomes a little more palatable once Jackie Chan enters the picture, cast as a Hong Kong inspector who teams up with Carter to crack the kidnaping of the Chinese Consul's 11-year-old daughter, a case that spans their respective countries. Chan fans might be disappointed by how little the master martial artist gets to simultaneously display his flair for physical comedy and killer moves; a scene where he battles bad guys while protecting the priceless exhibits in an art museum is classic Chan, a scene where his Carter-inspired use of a racial epithet gets him in trouble in a bar full of African-Americans is not.
That bit aside, "Rush Hour"'s humor of choice seems to be disparaging quips directed at Asians ("I've been lookin' for your sweet-and-sour chicken a--!" Carter screeches to a Chinese bad guy); it wouldn't be funny if it were the other way around, and it's not funny the way it is. Much more successful is the film's comedy when it plays up the culture clash between Chan and Tucker; this star and star-on-the-rise have a nice rapport both on-screen and off, the latter evidenced by the now-notorious Chan tradition of showing outtakes over the end credits. Here, it's good stuff worth sticking around for, especially when the two slip up together.
The title must refer to a gridlock of cliches instead of cars -- not only do we get the mismatched-buddy-cop story, we also get the fish-out-of-water and renegade-man-of-the-law angles and a climactic red-wire-or-blue-wire moment to top everything off. Though nobody will presumably accuse "Rush Hour" of breaking new cinematic ground, it's a tad on the disheartening side that this match made in odd couple heaven fails to enhance the familiar plot motions to memorable lengths. If you're a praying person, get on your knees - then, maybe Chan and Tucker will get a screenplay that's up to their collective speed in the inevitable "Rush Hour 2."
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews