Ghost in the Cel - Ghost in the Shell Review Director: Mamoru Oshii Reviewed by: Foong Ngai Hoe (Yukino Yoshi) ================================
When Ghost in the Shell (GitS) was released in 1995, it was probably one of the most eagerly-awaited full-length anime (Japanese animation) films since Katsuhiro Otomo's 1988 cyberpunk hit, Akira. Jointly financed by Manga Video, Kodansha, and Bandai Visuals, GitS became the first anime project to receive financial support outside Japan, and was subsequently launched simultaneously on both sides of the Pacific - in Japanese and English. Based on Shirow Masamune's manga (comics) series, the film was directed by Mamoru Oshii, one of Japan's top anime directors.
Major Motoko Kusanagi is an elite officer in the Section 9 security force, and along with fellow-cyborg Bateau and the mostly human Togusa, she is ordered to track down an illusive computer-criminal known only as the Puppet Master, a hacker who can hack into the minds of cyborgs. But the conspiracy unravels after Kusangi realises that the Puppet Master is in fact a renegade program belonging to one of the ministries which claims it's born "in a sea of information". As the ministries try to out-maneuver each other in a political game to retrieve the Puppet Master, the latter now turns its attention to Kusanagi. When the Major begins to question her own existence as a cyborg, the Puppet Master offers her a merger which will bring about a new life. This is where the story derives its name from - the 'ghost' being the soul a cyborg feels inside his or her shell (body).
Masamune's GitS is part political thriller, part social satire that access society in the digital age. Those familiar with his comics are quick to acknowledge the footnotes he attaches to his stories - some of them taking up chapters even. GitS is a difficult manga to read, made easier only by Masamune's brand of black humour.
GitS the movie isn't so much an Oshii's adaptation of Masamune's comics, but rather the director's own vision of it. Like in his Patlabor movies, Oshii brings to GitS a shade of noir that's become his trademark - tight camera angles, heavy shadow outlines, depressing colours, and a story that plods ponderously along.
Which is precisely the problem, depending on whether you like Oshii's style of direction or not. Too much of GitS involves either Kusanagi soul-searching, or long spells of dialogue off-screen while audiences are left staring at the backdrop. To be fair, Oshii's unique directional style does give many of the scenes a kind of poetry, but a less-appreciative audience might end up squirming uncomfortably in their seats. However, when the action does take place, it's often intense and gripping in ways many Hollywood action films aren't. Blood splatters across the screen, heads get blown off, but the violence is so well integrated into the action they don't seem too gratuitous.
The immense detail in the animation is breathtaking (even by today's standards) - from the dark and moody backdrops of Hong Kong in the 21st century, to the gunfights that punctuate the film. Kenji Kawaii's etheral score also lends to GitS the meditative feel the story needs.
In short, GitS is a technically brilliant and stylish animation, with a thought-provoking story you'd not find in western animation. Unfortunately, it's also a film too entrenched in its genre for its own good - with a plot so murky you might need a second viewing to fully understand it.
I'm not saying GitS is a poor production - on the contrary, it's a marvellous aural and visual treat. Yet as art often does, GitS will win many admirers but not converts. Neither is it likely to convince the west that Japanese animation's a lot more than robots, babes, and sex. And when you consider the amount of money poured into making this film a blockbuster, that's self-indulgence.
All said, GitS is still worth the watch if you've always wondered how Terminator 2 or Johnny Mnemonic might have turned out if animated. Without any doubt this a great work of art - it's how entertaining it is as a film that's open to debate.
Rating: 3.5/5
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews