CHAPLIN
A film review by James Berardinelli
Copyright 1993 James Berardinelli
Running Length: 2:24 Rated: PG-13 (Language, brief nudity, mature themes)
Starring: Robert Downey Jr., Paul Rhys, Moira Kelly, Geraldine Chaplin, Dan Aykroyd, Kevin Kline, Kevin Dunn, Diane Lane, Anthony Hopkins, Marisa Tomei, James Woods, Nancy Travis, Milla Jovovich, Penelope Ann Miller, John Thaw Director: Richard Attenborough Producers: Mario Kassar and Richard Attenborough Screenplay: William Goldman, William Boyd, and Bryan Forbes Music: John Barry Released by TriStar Pictures
CHAPLIN is Sir Richard Attenborough's recounting of the life and times of film great Charlie Chaplin. The story picks up in 1894, when Charlie is five, and lasts until 1972, five years before his death in 1977. Along the way, Attenborough gives us glimpses of Hollywood in its infancy, the filmmaking process, and McCarthyism. Above all, however, CHAPLIN shows the life, both on and off-screen, of one of the pioneers of motion pictures.
It's easy to pick out the single major flaw of CHAPLIN. It's too ambitious. Attempting to condense seventy-eight years into one-hundred adn forty-four minutes is a Herculean task that not even a director of Richard Attenborough's accomplishments is up to. There's too much material, and because the story is so rich, characters and events go whizzing by at dizzying speeds. CHAPLIN becomes a series of scenes and images rather than a cohesive whole.
Robert Downey Jr. does a highly credible Chaplin. Not only does he look like the comic, but he had mastered the physical mannerisms so necessary to the role. Downey said that copying "The Tramp" was his biggest challenge. It is also his most impressive accomplishment. In fact, the actor so perfectly captures his character that clips of the actual Chaplin can be used in the movie without ruining the illusion.
Aside from Chaplin, there is little attempt at character depth. Douglas Fairbanks (Kevin Kline, most recently of CONSENTING ADULTS), Sydney Chaplin (Paul Rhys), and Oona Chaplin (Moira Kelly, of THE CUTTING EDGE) are fleshed out a little, but none of them could be considered three-dimensional. It certainly isn't the actors' faults. Their characters have such limited screen time that it's difficult to do more than introduce them.
Choosing Geraldine Chaplin to play Charlie's mother Hannah is a case of inspired casting. Aside from Downey, she gives the most convincing portrayal, and even though her screen time is limited, she has presence in the scenes she's in.
Attenborough, with a flair for the subtle, cast Moira Kelly in a double role--that of Hetty Kelly, Charlie's lost love, and of Oona, with whom he had his only successful marriage. Kelly has trouble with the early role--or, more specifically, with Hetty's accent--but she does a fine job as Oona. The obvious resemblance between the two characters is never commented upon, so it's up to the viewer to make the connection. Unfortunately, this is another instance where the script fails. Since Hetty is only briefly introduced, it's hard to envision her as one of the forces that drives Chaplin's life, and even harder to understand how he is able to set aside her memory through Oona.
Indeed, emotional moments are few and far between in CHAPLIN. The only scene of any genuine power comes in the closing moments of the movie. Aside from that, watching the film is much like perusing a history textbook--informative and interesting, but not memorable or powerful. Fortunately, CHAPLIN is well-paced and snappily-plotted, so it never becomes dull or tedious. Early in the film, Mack Sennett (Dan Aykroyd) notes that Chaplin's first film appearance is on the cutting room floor--not a good place to be. One wonders how much of this picture ended up getting snipped. My sense is that there was a lot-- too much, perhaps--but it's difficult to imagine that any reasonable length could have been enough to do justice to the man's life. Seeing CHAPLIN has given me a strong desire to read the autobiography upon which the movie is based.
As expected from an Attenborough film, CHAPLIN boasts strong production values. The editing and camera work are smooth. There's a wonderful "life imitates art" scene where Chaplin is being chased by the police, and this couldn't have been better put together. The aging effects are some of the best I've seen. When Chaplin is old, he looks like he's being played by an elderly actor, not Robert Downey Jr. under a mountain of makeup. Veteran composer John Barry's score, while perhaps too reminiscent of his DANCES WITH WOLVES music, is evocative.
All-in-all, although CHAPLIN is solid entertainment, it's far from a magnificent film. As intellectually intriguing and satisfying as it is, the movie fails to touch enough emotional chords to make it of more than passing interest.
Rating: 7.9 (B, **1/2)
.
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews