A review by Peter Booth...
OK, let me start off by saying that this movie is of an entirely different calibre to the "previous" three. No, I'm not talking about the millions of dollars more injected into it, or the plethora of mind-bending special effects, but the feel.
It is one seriously disjointed film, and in places, ceases to make sense and becomes somewhat incoherent. The pre-release hype and marketing does the actual film almost zero justice. Darth Maul, portrayed as the next version of the Ultimate Bad Guy by fans and some elements of the press is largely a mute non-event...he says about three lines of dialogue in total and is hardly an imposing character, despite his devilish makeup. Nevertheless the scenes in which he actually fights are excellently choreographed and make the sabre duels of the "previous" three films look wooden and contrived. Back to the disjointed bit...well, the movie is about a trade embargo...ho hum, yawn yawn to most people. The trouble is, the actual embargo of Naboo doesn't seem to truly affect its citizens, nor is their any evidence of the "my people are dying" or "the deathtoll is catastrophic" allegations made earlier in the film...you just have to believe that this trade embargo is a Bad Thing. Why Darth Sidious/Senator Palpatine has bankrolled this manoeuvre in order to gain ascendancy is an odd decision. It is patently obvious that there must be better ways. It sort of flies in the face of what we are told in "The Journal of the Whills" back-story presented in the original Star Wars novelisation done in 1977...still, Star Wars is Lucas and he can do what he likes...and that's precisely what he has done here. One very large act of self-indulgence totally paid for by himself. It is chiefly disjointed by the almost total lack of character building. None of the protagonists of the film could be described as fleshed out, especially Qui-Gon Jinn and moreso Obi Wan Kenobi. They are virtually marionettes acting out Lucas' fairytale. Faceless folks running on rails, as it were. Ewan McGregor is woefully under-utilised, almost in a role of Neeson's yes-man and sidekick...both men are exceptional actors clearly struggling to portray characters which could only be classified as cardboard cut-outs... ...and kudos to anyone who understood Jar Jar Binks on first viewing...Ahmed Best makes him sound like some digital Charlie Chan on a bumbling excapade through life. The younger actors, Natalie Portman and Jake Lloyd do quite well, by comparison. I can't agree with elements out there that say Lloyd's performance was hammy and hollow. He is quite good in his role as boyhood Darth Vader even if at times, you feel he's playing some outrageous video game. Portman lends the film an air of gravitas; surprising for an actress of her age and experience with her steadfast denouncements of Federation intentions... Ian McDiarmid plays his dual roles as well as expected, especially as Senator Palpatine, representative of Naboo...the consummate politician, appeasing all comers and all sides.
Well, I've been all negative so far...what good was in this film? Everything else, essentially. There have been enough reviews of the jaw-dropping SFX posted for me to make further impression, but they are eminently effective, and don't necessarily drown out the uneven plot and development. The "flight" of the Gungan craft as it swims through the planet's core is excellent, with amazing creatures seeking to make this ship their next meal...quite awesome. The pod race is simply amazing too, not only for the vertiginous ride it gives you, but the hilarity in the alien participants...the Humpty-Dumpty look-a-like who stalls at the start had me in stitches as did the expression on the face of another as he is about to collide with a canyon outcropping... ...and then we had Tusken Raiders taking potshots at racers along the way... ...and a two-headed race commentator...
The entire pod race sequence is quite a delight. Sebulba is the ultimate win at all costs hot rodder, and a bizarre little creature who walks on his hands.
Lucas goes for laughs quite often in his battle sequences...the Federation's droids coming undone at the hands of blue electric balls unleashed by the Gungans is comical, as is Lucas' penchant for severed limbs and people going bump on things they shouldn't...
In essence, the Phantom Menace is a good film...nothing phenomenal or abysmal...simply a good film that needed some serious ironing out, especially in the categories of plot and character development...you are left feeling that none of these players can be taken seriously, something hammered into you in the "previous" three films...you did take Darth Vader seriously...Darth Maul or the Viceroy of the Trade Federation? Cartoons...
On a final note...I swear I saw E.T's in the Republican Senate chamber...this has probably been discussed in various SW forums/newsgroups to death and is possibly common knowledge among SW cognoscenti, but as I don't frequent them, i don't know if that' in fact what they were. Wouldn't surprise me considering Lucas' friendship with Spielberg.
In summary...a wooden, cartoony movie giving a taste of more serious matters to come in 2002 and 2005. Don't pick holes in the plot, for you'll find them in plenitude, don't admire the characterisation of the protagonists too closely, but sit back, and simply enjoy a visual and aural blast of a film...
Peter Booth -- Cybiades: ICQ# 2822923 Computing for fun! http://www.ticnet.com/azenomei/fels/fels.html The antepenultimate place on the WWW! Essendon, Zimbabwe, Oporto Portuguese Chicken Victoria Bitter, and a cast of thousands
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews