UNCLE MOSES (directors: Sidney Goldin/Aubrey Scotto; screenwriter:from book by Sholem Asch/Maurice Schwartz; cinematographer: Frank Zucker; cast: Maurice Schwartz (Uncle Moses), Rubin Goldberg (Moses' Father), Judith Abarbanel (Masha), Zvee Scooler (Charlie), Mark Schweid (Aaron), Rebecca Weintraub (Gnendel), Sam Gertler (Sam), Michael Rosenberg (Moishe Gross), Sally Schorr (Rosie), Jacob Mestel (Berel), Leon Seidenberg (Mannes), Shirley Zelany (Tsirl), 1932-Yiddish)
Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz
Sidney Goldin codirected Maurice Schwartz (Uncle Moses) in this film from Schwartz's stage adaptation of Sholem Asch's 1918 novel. It was one of the early Yiddish talkies to date and one of the most prestigious. Schwartz was celebrated as being the 'Olivier of the Yiddish stage.'He is one of the world's greatest actors (he was Tevye in Fiddler on the Roof) but he is not as recognizable a name as he should be. This comedy/romance that turns dramatic, should give you a good idea of how great an actor he is. The film depicts the old-world values as it clashes over the new-world dreams, and it is played out by seeing the traditional Jewish family undergo tremendous changes in their lifestyle, as they must adapt to the ways of their new country.
The patriarchal Uncle Moses is the antihero rich clothing manufacturer and twisted namesake of his Biblical counterpart. He left the East Europe of Kuzmin, where he was a struggling butcher, and where there was widespread poverty and persecution of the Jews, to come to America, the promised land, and start his tailor business in the crowded Jewish ghetto on the Lower East Side of NYC. As crude and as vile a man as he is, the benevolent despot brought his landsman from the shtetl (Jewish village) to America and got them jobs and took care of them. Their end of the bargain, was that they worked in his sweatshop for 14-hours a workday and they only received minimum wages, as he did not allow them to belong to a union. For his end of the bargain, he treated them as family, paid for treating their illnesses, acted as a benefactor for them, and showed signs of generosity to them and those landsmen still back in Kuzmin, giving freely to charity. He was Uncle Moses and the workers accepted him as their patron and savior.
The first talking scene in the film indicates the complexity of the Uncle Moses character, as a rabbi from his old shtetl visits his clothing factory to solicit a donation. Moses is busy dealing with the two women he had affairs with- the wife of a luncheonette owner and a Polish shikse (gentile). The scene belies his ability at manipulation, as the tricky boss and the rabbi with his hands out go after what they both want from each other, as the rabbi amuses the patriarch by chanting a Yom Kippur prayer, that brings out the nostalgia in Moses, who doesn't let the rabbi forget for a moment who has the money and the power, as he donates money to the synagagogue and to a cemetery in Kuzmin. Uncle Moses enjoys his Moses role that he plays to his people, which teases his vanity and his sentimental side. Though he is not a religious man, he respects the traditions, as the film makes many Biblical allusions in telling its story.
His nephew Sam (Gertler) runs the factory. He is Americanized, preferring to speak in English and is disliked by the workers for being a nasty tyrant. He follows his widowed uncle around, acting as his flunky. His hope is that his childless uncle doesn't marry and that he will inherit all his money.
Moses' father (Rubin Goldberg), plays the Shakespearian-like fool who speaks the truth even if he appears as if he is crazy. He goes through the factory chanting a catchy melody and bitterly denouncing his son in a joking manner and denouncing the capitalistic system of his new country, wishing to go back to the old country and be buried there. He compares his son to Tsar Nicholas and to the Pharaoh. The father says that he is the real Moses - that he will lead the Jewish workers in this sweltering sweatshop out of bondage and take them to the sea.
One of Moses' workers pokes fun at his huge belly and is fired. The cowardly worker (Schweid) brings his 17-year-old attractive daughter Masha (Abarbanel) to beg Moses to give him his job back. When Moses shows a romantic interest in the girl and is ready to do something for her father, but his flunkies in the background encourage Moses to make fun of her cowering father, she lashes out at him, calling him a beast, a brute, and a dog! Moses likes the spirit she shows defending her father and gives him back his old job at the machine and with a raise. The much older Moses will woo the reluctant Masha for a year, showering her family with gifts, shaving his beard and going to the gym to lose weight for her sake. The parents will see this romance as an opportunity to better their lot in life and push their daughter to accept his marriage proposal, not caring one bit that she doesn't love him. Meanwhile, Charlie (Zvee), the young Marxist follower who lives in her tenement building, whom she is in love with, rails against her decision to marry the wealthy boss. He will get involved with the union and start organizing the workers.
The most memorable scene in the film, is the attempt to have a traditional wedding ceremony, as the wedding takes place in his in-laws fifth-floor walk-up apartment, where there is traditional song and dancing, and a shot of the forlorn Charlie watching the wedding from his apartment window that faces Masha's.
On the day that Masha gives birth to a son, the union strikes his shop, and Moses is disappointed that his workers would go behind his back and do this to him, telling them how much he did for them, though he is still ready to sit down with them and work things out. But his in-law insults Charlie and the strike takes place, as he turns his attention to his baby and let's Sam handle the strike. Sam breaks up the strike by using thugs, something Moses is repelled about and vows to never let something like that happen again.
But Uncle Moses' way of life radically changes, as his wife can't find satisfaction in the marriage, even though she tells him that she likes him better than she does her parents. This all gets to Moses, who will have a heart attack over the strike. He also agrees to divorce Masha. He loses interest in running all his businesses and decides to make out a will, leaving a quarter of his estate to the workers.
The times have changed for the immigrant Jews, as they had to choose between two bad choices-the false family of the transposed shetl or the emerging false family of the union. Moses becomes a symbol of the past, as he is relegated to a sentimental and irrelevant role in the future. The last shot in the movie is ultimately a sad one, of him coming back to visit his family of workers, as he requests one of them to sing a familiar nostalgic melody, and he proceeds to tell them a story of what a man is, how a man builds houses, factories, brings his countrymen to America, and after all, the grave awaits him.
The evils of American materialism is matched with a disdainful look at the old-world economics and the old way of arranging marriages, of the parents disregarding what their children want and acting as benovolent tyrants over them. America is now a place for inspiration for the younger generation, Yiddish will not be their first-tongue, and the rich opportunities in the new land will take precedence over everything else. Masha will be viewed as a victim, caught in the changing times, who did not marry for money herself, but only to please her parents, an obligation she believed that she had to fulfill. Moses will be looked upon with mixed emotions, with some fond memories of him for his charitable nature and some disappointments that he was an exploiter. He will be viewed as a representative from a time when the immigrants were in a transitional state in their new country, when they lived in poverty and strived to have their children gain the fruits of the American dream.
REVIEWED ON 12/31/99 GRADE: A
Dennis Schwartz: "Ozus' World Movie Reviews"
http://www.sover.net/~ozus
ozus@sover.net
© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED DENNIS SCHWARTZ
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews