Review by Lars Lindahl
"What Planet Are You From?" (2000)
Directed by Mike Nichols Written by Michael Leeson, Garry Shandling, Ed Solomon, and Peter Tolan
Starring Garry Shandling, Annette Bening, Greg Kinnear, Ben Kingsley, Linda Fiorentino, and John Goodman.
What Planet Are You From? can be divided into three distinct segments. First we follow alien Harold Anderson (Garry Shandling) on his mission to impregnate a woman on earth. Far and away the funniest segment of the film (despite the fact that it is one long extended joke), it remains consistently amusing. We don't know exactly why he is trying to woo an earth woman but it is still funny. The dialogue is fresh, the characters are well introduced, and the premise is original. The most hilarious and ironic joke of this segment is that this clueless alien, just trying to complete a revolutionary mission for his planet is indistinguishable from some obnoxious earth jerk just trying to score.
For this reason, Harold finds himself interacting and bonding with sexist perverts such as Perry (Greg Kinnear) at his fake job. His relationship with these characters makes up the second segment of the film. At this point, What Planet? begins to lose some of its fresh humor and originality as it shifts from Harold's desperate search to succeed for his planet to a disappointing who's-sleeping-with-who-and-why ensemble piece. The segment contains way too many pointless side stories that would have made the movie better if they did not exist at all. Who cares if Perry and Harold are competing for a vice president position at their job? Or if the man trying to find out exactly who Harold is (John Goodman) is having marital problems at home? The answers to these questions only distract the viewer from the central point.
The third segment has Harold taking the next step by marrying a former alcoholic, Susan, (Annette Bening) in hopes of improving his chances to have a child. There are some very memorable scenes between Susan and Harold, but these pleasant moments surprisingly lead up to one of the most idiotic endings I've seen in a long time. The characters become excessively cartoonish and, out of nowhere, the script gives them extremely foolish lines. It gets mushy and overly dramatic in some areas and way too slapstick in other areas. It almost seems like a different screenwriter or director contributed at this point with completely opposite ideas of how the characters should act and talk.
When examining the film as a whole, it is a disappointment, because only one segment is totally satisfying. Despite some lively performances from the talented cast, the script does not have enough energy to keep up. It seems like there was only one real joke within What Planet? and that joke was quickly overused just as the first segment was ending. If only the movie was a 40 minute short in which Harold gets the girl, has sex, gets the girl pregnant, and leaves. It might have worked, and if not, the short would have been a lot better than the real thing, a 120 minute movie that didn't work. For true entertainment in which aliens pretend to be humans with hilarious consequences, watch Third Rock from the Sun. It's amazing how that show has been funny for years now using the same joke that What Planet Are You From? couldn't make funny for two hours.
Grade: ** (out of four stars)
Lars Attacks! http://www.angelfire.com/ny3/larsattacks
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews