QUO VADIS? (director: Mervyn LeRoy; screenwriter: from book by Henryk Sienkiewicz/ S.N. Behrmann/Sonya Levien/John Lee Mahin; cinematographer: Robert Surtees/William Skall; editor: Ralph Winters; cast: Robert Taylor (Marcus Vinicius), Deborah Kerr (Lygia), Peter Ustinov (Nero), Leo Genn (Petronius), Patricia Laffan (Poppaea), Finlay Currie (Peter), Abraham Sofaer (Paul), Rosalie Crutchley (Acte), Marina Berti (Eunice), Buddy Baer (Ursus), Ralph Truman (Tigellinus), Felix Aylmer (Plautius), 1951)
Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz
A glossy MGM extravaganza of a bible film, more pleasing to watch for its conspicuous opulence than for its dramatics, dialogue, or politics. Directed with a mixture of tedium and oomph by Mervyn LeRoy, as this Roman spectacle set in 64 A.D., at the time of Nero's rule, runs for close to three hours before Nero decides to do the honorable thing and stick a knife in himself to say he's done.
Commanding General (Marcus Vinicius) of the 14th legion returns to Rome after three years of victorious battle in Britannia. He returns to a corrupt Rome under its nefarious Emperor, the 29-year-old Nero, who killed his mother and his wife, and loves to think of himself as an artistic soul, living a debauched life with harems and flatterers surrounding him, as he plays a bad lyre and sings choppy verses to praise himself as a greater god than Jupiter. His empress is the lustful and cunning Poppaea (Laffan), who is having an affair with his head of the Praetorian Guard, Tigellinus (Truman), right under his curly blonde locks of hair.
The plot concerns the romance between a beautiful early Christian woman, Lygia (Deborah Kerr) and the initially agnostic Roman commander Marcus. They meet when the war-weary, woman-starved soldier is a guest in her adopted father's house, the former Roman general, who has now secretly become a Christian. She is physically attracted to the handsome and athletic man, but is unappreciative of his fighting skills and soldier's attitude.
Marcus' uncle Petronius (Genn) is one of Nero's counselors who knows how to flatter him best and gain for himself the emperor's favors. He owns many slaves and one of the slaves is a beautiful girl who loves him unabashedly, Eunice (Berti). Marcus is told by his cynical uncle that he can get the emperor to grant him what he wants for the conquests he brought to Rome and suggests he takes a rulership in Egypt, but his nephew instead wants the emperor to turn Lygia over to his care. Anyone who would choose Deborah Kerr over Egypt deserves to be cheered as a true Christian convert!
Lygia is dismayed to be with the soldier who tries to take her by force, as she would rather be in her father's gentle house and take part in the secret Christian rituals in the catacombs outside the walls of Rome. Even Peter comes here to explain his apostle days with Christ and how he fulfilled Christ's prophecy by denying him three times after the crucifixion, but has come to Rome to build the Christian church as prophesized by Christ. She also has interesting houseguests, like the radical rabbi, Paul of Tarsus, who is on a mission across the Roman Empire to spread the word of Christ and helps her keep the faith by discussing the gospel.
The stability of the Roman chaos is broken when Nero has this mad idea of burning down Rome and building it over in his image. He burns it down and is pleased with the flames he sees and plays the lyre while Rome burns. But when things go badly and the Roman mobs are ready to attack him for destroying their homes and so many lives, Poppaea comes up with this bright idea of blaming the Christians for it. She does this primarily because she is scorned by Marcus and jealous of Lygia.
Marcus chooses love over the empire and saves Lygia, her giant bodyguard Ursus (Baer), and her family from the fire, by getting the Roman soldiers to open up the gates to the city and let the people in. But when the mob hears Nero's accusations of the Christians causing the fire, the mob turns against the Christians, and, Marcus is rounded up with all the other Christians and jailed. Petronius says of Nero's lie, that people will believe any lie, if it is fantastic enough.
Now Marcus and Lygia must find a way to stop the lions from killing them in the Colosseum.
Quo Vadis? was a big money grosser for the studio in the pre-CinemaScope era. They shot the film in Italy, with a cast of thousands. At the time, it was only second to GWTW in how much cabbage it brought in. It had a lot of spectacular shots and was well-paced, but it was not a particularly moving experience. One of the shots I preferred, was of Nero looking through a a piece of green glass at an orgy while Poppaea looked at it through a red glass. They had such different perspectives, you see. Peter Ustinov's delightful over-the-top sissy performance was fun to watch. There was also a giant killing a bull in the arena, Peter crucified upside-down, and a beautiful fire to view. They don't make them like this one anymore because it costs too much and the studios are not sure if the crowds will come again.
REVIEWED ON 5/11/2000 GRADE: C
Dennis Schwartz: "Ozus' World Movie Reviews"
© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED DENNIS SCHWARTZ
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews