Alien 3
Chad'z rating: ** (out of 4 = fair)
1992, R, 115 minutes [1 hour, 55 minutes]
[science fiction]
starring: Sigourney Weaver (Ripley), Charles S. Dutton (Dillon), Charles Dance (Clemens), Paul McGann (Golic); written by David Giler, Walter Hill, Larry Ferguson, Vincent Ward; produced by Gordon Carroll, Walter Hill, David Giler; directed by David Fincher; based on characters created by Dan O'Bannon, Ronald Shusett.
Seen November 23, 1997 on home video (borrowed from my sister's roommate).
During the opening credits to "Alien 3" I could tell it was going to be different from the others in the series, and that gave me high hopes. And there is a major difference here that is somewhat of a relief, but at the same time the difference is the problem. If the other films failed from excessiveness, this one fails from depravity and blandness.
Like the first two films, the opening sequence has the credits appearing over the void of space. But this time they are intercut with quick images of something strange happening on the ship Ripley (Weaver) and the survivors used to escape from the alien planet. And wouldn't you know it - one of those pesky aliens somehow got on the ship too.
Ripley's ship crash lands on a desolate planet used as a prison for violent criminals, who seem to have formed some sort of cult. They have little technology but manage to save only Ripley.
The first third is extremely slow in its storytelling. Almost nothing happens in terms of plot development, instead we just get interaction between Ripley and the prison doctor, Clemens (Dance), and the cult leader Dillon (Dutton). The alien itself is barely shown, only in the shadows, and in disorienting shots at that (how original). Somehow a larvae is imbedded in a dog's body, and during a scene in which Ripley, Clemens, and Dillon cremate the bodies of Newt and Hicks, we see it be "born" while Dillon recites an eerie eulogy.
At first I was intrigued by the Gothic atmosphere here, and the aforementioned scenes built up at least some suspense. It's clear Fincher wants to do something different, and for that I applaud him. However, just when he had us in the palm of his hand and ready to squeeze, he lets us go by allowing the story to become a complete re-tread of the first two films. Ripley never mentions the aliens and her experience until almost the halfway point, and of course when she does no one believes her. Therefore, is it surprising the most cynical, easy-to-hate character is killed by the alien for all to see?
You would think once some semblance of plot and conflict is established the film would have direction. Unfortunately the second half is just as slowly paced as the first. Not only that, but we get many of the same old gimmicks such as Ripley and the others having to wait a long time for a rescue party; the fact there are almost no weapons; supporting characters getting killed by the alien; and of course lots of tunnels, drains, and other places for the alien to hide, and for the people to trap themselves in.
The last act contains the same old climax with the five-minute countdown that will "certainly" lead to the alien's doom, but kills off more supporting characters in the process. Fincher at least shoots these scenes in a bizarre manner that gives one a sense a vertigo. Elements like this crop up throughout the picture and it's a shame they weren't taken advantage of.
It's not that "Alien 3" is a bad movie per se, there's just not enough to appreciate.
To receive Chad'z movie reviews directly, send e-mail to ChadPolenz@aol.com with "subscribe" in the header.
(C) 1997 Chad Polenz
The review above was posted to the
rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the
review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright
belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due
to ASCII to HTML conversion.
Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews